The Edgartown Conservation Commission has thrown the first hurdle in the way of Vineyard Wind, an 84-turbine wind farm off the island. The commission last week denied Vineyard Wind’s application to run electric cables from the turbines to the mainland. The cables would run about a mile east of Chappaquiddick.

The plan has been approved by the Martha’s Vineyard Commission, the Nantucket Conservation Commission and the Cape Cod Commission.

The Edgartown commission held a hearing on the cables several weeks ago, which, according to the Vineyard Gazette, involved some five hours of testimony from a dozen commercial fishermen and environmental activists. The Gazette described the exchanges as “heated and at times passionate.”

The fishermen claimed that the cables could pose a risk to the fishery and hence their livelihood. The testimony sowed enough doubt among the commissioners that they voted 5-1 last week against the project.

It was an extreme case of short-term versus long-term planning. Unfortunately, the Edgartown Conservation Commission acted on short-term concerns.

It is difficult to understand. One would think the commission would have seen that the imagined threat of underwater cables is nothing compared to the very real threat of climate change. And it won’t be only fishermen who have to deal with its effects.

For some reason, commercial fishermen have garnered the sympathy of politicians and government officials, and they have caved to their entreaties for protection time and again. And it has never worked out well. The oceans fisheries, near and far, have been impacted severely by overfishing and yet policy makers do as little as possible to curtail commercial fishing. There is nothing new here.

One would think that, after all this time, the concerns of commercial fishermen would be put aside for the long-term future of the planet.

(2) comments

FrankHaggerty

The news media, state, and ocean wind turbine company make reference to the 2 (two) electric cables as 400 megawatts Each cable carries up to 200,000 volts of electricity for a total of 400,000 volts - What is the safety setbacks for a 200Kv electric cable Underwater noise: There are clear indications that underwater noise caused by the installation of sub-sea cables poses a high risk of harming marine fauna. There is a potential for disturbance of fish and marine mammals. Like the Falmouth land-based wind turbines mitigation measures should be considered as a precaution in sensitive areas. Electromagnetic fields: Electromagnetic fields are generated by 200 Kv operational ocean power cables. Heat: When high voltage electric energy is transported, a certain amount gets lost as heat, leading to increased temperature of the cable surface and subsequent warming of the surrounding environment. There is evidence that various marine organisms react sensitively to an even minor increase in the ambient temperature. Send the cables to Fall River

Gadfly

Send the cables to Fall River? Aren't they on the same planet over there? So let's see, we shut down Pilgrim, there is a war against natural gas pipelines being brought into Mass., coal is dead, and the Sun only produces solar energy during the day. I think I'll start a candle business.

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
PLEASE TURN OFF YOUR CAPS LOCK.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.